Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Thomas Fridrich's avatar

Thanks for the synthesis!

Beyond structural market shifts, you highlighted essential organizational changes regarding the operational lifetime of assets. However, additional organizational adjustments are needed at the corporate level. Historically, generous FiTs or fixed PPAs ensured almost every project appeared economical. As a result, many renewable developers never built monthly P&L forecasting systems or risk management systems. And some renewable companies have grown from a 5-ppl shop into large corporations without scaling their internal control structures accordingly.

A good example is ABO Energy, which went from forecasting an initial EUR 30m profit, to a EUR 95m net loss, and ultimately to a EUR 170m net loss within weeks following write-downs and project delays. Another recent case is Energiekontor, which slashed its 2026 EBT guidance from EUR 40m–60m down to EUR 5m–10m in a sudden ad hoc announcement released just hours later. Both cases highlight a lack of visibility and portfolio management practices (and maybe handled in irregularly updated spreadsheets....).

Having worked in both renewable development and upstream oil & gas, the difference in risk culture and project managment is visible. Upstream E&P projects have a high level of complexity (reservoir, drilling, facilities, etc.), subsurface and above ground risks (commercial, geopolitical, etc.), and manage it through rigid stage-gate decision processes. In my experience, onshore renewable developers have rarely applied these gated frameworks (offshore projects are differently handled since the market is dominated by larger players and utilities). However, as commerical complexity and associated risks grow, adopting stage-gate process is becoming mandatory to ensure efficient and sustainable capital allocation in projects.

Edoardo Coletti's avatar

Spot on post !

An electrical system with more complex markets and business models will increase risks and costs.

We need simplification. A system of non-synchronous network of networks where batteries play a key role.

Generation should be viewed as tool to charge batteries.

13 more comments...

Ready for more?